Comments on: Why are cows holy in India?

By: Zara

Zara — Tue, 17 Nov 2015 11:59:03 +0000

Hi Polu!
This is a very good explanation.
Thanks for sharing your knowledge here! :)

By: Prasad

Prasad — Sat, 14 Nov 2015 17:50:21 +0000

Hi,

The apathetic treatment of cows in India is mostly an urban phenomenon, where people don’t have time for anything except their job and fun, you know. I hail from a small city in India, but even there, when a cow roams around the neighbourhood, we offer it something to eat, like a banana or two. The local dairy cows usually wait at the gate sometimes to see if someone offers them food. Many families do offer them food. As for making them work, it’s actually the bulls and oxen that work in the fields, not the cows. And they are taken care of, humanely. The religion teaches people to treat cow as your mother and bull/ox as your father due to their roles in human lives (like the mother nourishes and the father works to feed the family) and due to the kind of animals they are (very affectionate and loving). They are like part of the family, like the West treats dogs. Now you don’t eat your family or mistreat them, right?

By: polu

polu — Fri, 04 Sep 2015 14:04:09 +0000

i dont know what you are talking about but as a hindu i know cows are more holy than humans as the are far more accountable and trusted than humans, cows and buffalows are the greatest invention of gods, i live in a desert state in india and the food to us is milk and some barley and rye all time in year, this is only how we survive in our place, we burn dung for cooking lighting nd warmth, eat goats. like they do in south sudan. we here dont have electricity, no water supply or roads, just dust trails, waterholes and we go to nearest cities about 72 km away to charge tractor batteries so that back home we can charge our cellphones, even after 66 years of independence, our human politicians betrayed us but our holy cows and buffalows stood by us giving us so much that we are in debt to them and so they are holy to us, and i think as a person of first wold country you will see that it is not very difficult to understand. it is a fact cows are holy and our mothers.

By: Zara

Zara — Tue, 01 Apr 2014 17:08:43 +0000

The story is indeed charming… but then, why are some cows exploited for work?! Would that mean that a hindu god could be getting exploited?! Man, Hindu mythology is very rich and intense!.. ;)

By: Zara

Zara — Tue, 01 Apr 2014 17:06:45 +0000

No, I don’t think they belong to anyone as such. And I’ve never seen anyone milking them either. They way they are skinny, I am not even sure they have milk and all. What I do see is sometimes people giving them food. I think this happens particularly on Tuesdays (for religious reasons), and some even make fresh chapatis (Indian flat breads) for them! Crazy!..

By: Irina

Irina — Sat, 20 Jul 2013 02:30:50 +0000

Yep, Holy Cow is a good book! I haven’t been to India yet, but the descriptions were very vivid.

By: Irina

Irina — Sat, 20 Jul 2013 02:28:09 +0000

So do these cows roaming the street actually belong to someone? I’ve heard they are supposed to be milked regularly for health reasons. And if so, someone must have been doing it.

By: PS (Plus-Size) Backpacker

PS (Plus-Size) Backpacker — Mon, 13 May 2013 12:21:31 +0000

I heard that an avatar of a hindu god was once turned into a cow and they never found out which cow it was, therefore, they don’t take any chance and avoid killing them… I have no idea if it’s true or pure invention, but I kinda loved the story! :)

By: Chandler

Chandler — Mon, 13 May 2013 08:24:42 +0000

You are right, on one hand cows are being treated like no one care about them and on the other they consider them holy, its weird. I am in India right now and I can see many cows and calves running on the main roads, sitting on the streets and causing traffic jam. I have seen people putting red dot on cow’s head, it seemed like people were worshiping cows.

By: Zara

Zara — Mon, 29 Apr 2013 17:21:13 +0000

Hey Belle!
I have actually read Holy Cow, the book.. quite funny! ;)
The way cows are treated in India is indeed weird.. holy on one hand, eating plastic and dying on the other. I guess in a place where there’s many people in need too, no one’s going to take that good care of cows.. whether they’re [theoretically] holy or not. Each man on its own… each cow on its own too, I suppose.

By: Belle

Belle — Fri, 19 Apr 2013 19:20:34 +0000

Again, I just commented on your previous post about Turkey & India and found your comments on the holiness of cow’s quite interesting! Hindu’s believe the cow’s to be so holy, yet they treat them horribly, in fact, I’m sure this is a tale of bad Karma, but once when I was on a train in India the train actually ran over a cow causing us to be delayed for many hours, i’m not sure what the repurcussions for the train driver were, but i’m sure he or she believes they are in for some bad Karma in their next life! If you love India, you should read the book Holy Cow, an Indian Adventure! It will make you laugh, smile and relate in so many ways!